Cold email reply rate benchmarks
Across 6,074,430 cold emails sent between October 2023 and October 2026, the average human reply rate is 1.6% per prospect contacted and 0.8% per email sent. Including auto-replies those become 3.2% and 1.6%. Auto-replies are 51% of everything that lands in the reply folder, which is why most published benchmarks are roughly double their real value.
- 1.6% human replies per prospect, 0.8% per email sent. Including auto-replies, 3.2% and 1.6%.
- Auto-replies are 51% of all replies. About 49,000 out-of-office against 48,000 human, so any benchmark that does not separate them overstates reply rate by about 2x.
- Industry matters more than copy. Cleaning and janitorial replies three times better than SaaS and tech, 1.2% against 0.4% per email sent.
- One in seven human replies is positive. 6,472 positive replies and 1,728 booked meetings from 6.07 million emails.
- Per prospect or per send decides everything. The same campaign reports 1.6% or 0.8% depending on the denominator, and most published benchmarks never say which they used.
Every figure on this page comes from Grow Surely's own Instantly workspaces: 28 accounts, 1,568 campaigns, 6,074,430 emails sent to roughly 3.0 million prospects. The method is stated in full, including what was excluded and why.
- What is a good cold email reply rate?
- Why most published rates are twice too high
- Why published benchmarks disagree
- Reply rates by industry
- Who gets the most robot replies
- Per email or per prospect?
- What share of replies are positive?
- How many emails is one booked meeting?
- Why a good campaign beats the average
- How this was measured
- What this data does not show
- Citing this data
- How to use these benchmarks
What is a good cold email reply rate?
Across 6,074,430 emails, the average human reply rate is 1.6% per prospect contacted, or 0.8% per email sent. Including auto-replies, those become 3.2% and 1.6%. A campaign landing above 2% human replies per prospect is doing well. Below 1% usually means the list, not the copy.
That is the whole answer, and the rest of this page is why those four numbers differ so much from the ones usually quoted.
| Measure | Per prospect contacted | Per email sent |
|---|---|---|
| Human replies only | 1.6% | 0.8% |
| Including auto-replies | 3.2% | 1.6% |
| Positive replies | 0.2% | 0.1% |
Sample: 6,074,430 emails to roughly 3.0 million unique prospects, across 28 Instantly workspaces and 1,568 campaigns, sent between 30 October 2023 and 12 October 2026. About 87% of that volume is from 2026.
These are averages across every campaign in the dataset, including ones that failed. A well-run campaign on a well-built list clears them by a wide margin, and the section on why a good campaign beats the average covers what that looks like.
Why are most published reply rates twice what they should be?
Because out-of-office replies get counted as replies. In this dataset there were roughly 49,000 auto-replies against 48,000 human replies, so auto-replies make up 51% of everything that lands in the reply folder. Any benchmark that does not separate them is reporting a number about twice its real value.
This is the single most common distortion in published cold email statistics, and it is not usually deliberate. Sending platforms count a reply as a reply. Nobody opens 97,000 messages to sort them.
| What landed in the reply folder | Count | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Auto-replies and out-of-office | ~49,000 | 51% |
| Human replies | ~48,000 | 49% |
| Of which positive | 6,472 | 13% of human replies |
The practical consequence: when a vendor quotes a 3% reply rate, ask whether that is human replies. If they do not know, it is probably about 1.5%. If a campaign dashboard shows replies climbing while the calendar stays empty, the auto-reply share is usually the explanation.
There is a second reason the gap matters. Auto-replies are not noise, they are information. An out-of-office confirms the address is live and monitored, which is a deliverability signal worth tracking. It is just not interest, and counting it as interest is how a campaign looks healthy for six weeks while producing nothing.
Why published cold email benchmarks disagree so violently
Search for a cold email reply rate benchmark and the published figures run from under 1% to well above 10%. They are not all wrong. Most of them are measuring different things and almost none of them say which, so the numbers are not comparable in the first place.
There are four structural reasons, and recognising them is worth more than memorising any single figure.
1. The denominator is usually unstated. Replies divided by emails sent and replies divided by prospects contacted differ by whatever the follow-up count is. In this dataset that is about two emails per prospect, so the same campaign reads 0.8% or 1.6% depending purely on which line the author picked. A benchmark that does not name its denominator cannot be compared with anything.
2. Auto-replies are usually left in. Out-of-office notices, bounce notifications and autoresponders are 51% of everything that comes back here. Any tool reporting a raw reply count without classification is reporting roughly double the human figure, and most do.
3. Survivorship. A vendor publishing its own benchmark has every incentive to draw from accounts that worked. Dead campaigns, churned clients and the first clumsy months rarely make it into the sample. The aggregate on this page deliberately keeps all of them, which is why it reads lower than most published figures and why the working-account table sits beside it.
4. Mixed eras and mixed markets. Reply rates fell as inbox filtering tightened and cold email volume rose, so a figure from 2021 describes a different internet. Industry mix moves it just as hard: the spread between the top and bottom rows in the table above is threefold, so a benchmark drawn mostly from one vertical says little about another.
The practical rule. Before accepting any published reply rate, ask three questions: per email or per prospect, are auto-replies included, and how many failed campaigns are in the sample. If a source cannot answer all three, the number is not a benchmark, it is a marketing claim. Those answers for this page are in how this was measured.
Cold email reply rates by industry
Reply rate varies more by industry than by almost anything else a sender controls. Industry-specific breakdowns of what this means in practice are covered separately for financial services. Cleaning and janitorial replies at 1.2% per email sent; SaaS and tech at 0.4%. That is a threefold spread driven by inbox volume and how used to cold outreach each market has become.
| Industry | Emails sent | Campaigns | Human reply | Incl. auto | Positive |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cleaning & janitorial | 235,000 | 57 | 1.2% | 2.0% | 0.18% |
| Restaurants, bars & hotels | 310,000 | 121 | 1.0% | 1.8% | 0.18% |
| Med spas & healthcare | 90,000 | 62 | 1.0% | 1.6% | 0.12% |
| Recruiting & staffing | 290,000 | 39 | 0.8% | 1.3% | 0.09% |
| Finance, funding & lending | 160,000 | 52 | 0.7% | 1.4% | 0.10% |
| Home services & trades | 770,000 | 231 | 0.6% | 1.0% | 0.08% |
| Professional services | 220,000 | 50 | 0.6% | 2.0% | 0.08% |
| Marketing agencies | 330,000 | 102 | 0.5% | 1.7% | 0.09% |
| Manufacturing & distribution | 180,000 | 71 | 0.5% | 1.5% | 0.05% |
| SaaS & tech | 365,000 | 64 | 0.4% | 1.3% | 0.10% |
All figures are per email sent. The dataset averages about two emails per prospect, so per-prospect rates run roughly double these.
Three patterns are worth pulling out of that table.
The hardest markets are the ones that buy software. SaaS and tech sits last at 0.4%, and marketing agencies are second from last at 0.5%. Both are populated by people who run outbound themselves, receive a great deal of it, and recognise a sequence on sight. Selling to someone who writes cold email for a living is the hardest version of this job.
Professional services has the widest gap between human and auto. 0.6% human against 2.0% including auto, so more than two thirds of what arrives is an out-of-office. Accounting and legal firms run heavy auto-responders. A campaign into that market will look like it is working long before it is.
Volume is not quality. Home services is the largest segment in the dataset at 770,000 emails and sits mid-table on reply rate with the second-lowest positive rate. A market being large and reachable does not make it responsive.
Who gets the most robot replies, and why it splits the market in two
The industry table carries both a human reply rate and a rate including auto-replies, and the gap between the two columns turns out to be the most consistent pattern in the whole dataset. It is not published anywhere else because it needs both denominators side by side, and almost nobody reports both.
| Industry | Human reply | Incl. auto | Share of replies that are automatic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marketing agencies | 0.5% | 1.7% | ~71% |
| Professional services | 0.6% | 2.0% | ~70% |
| SaaS & tech | 0.4% | 1.3% | ~69% |
| Manufacturing & distribution | 0.5% | 1.5% | ~67% |
| Finance, funding & lending | 0.7% | 1.4% | ~50% |
| Restaurants, bars & hotels | 1.0% | 1.8% | ~44% |
| Cleaning & janitorial | 1.2% | 2.0% | ~40% |
| Home services & trades | 0.6% | 1.0% | ~40% |
| Recruiting & staffing | 0.8% | 1.3% | ~39% |
| Med spas & healthcare | 1.0% | 1.6% | ~38% |
The market splits cleanly in two. Desk-based B2B markets run 67% to 71% automatic. Field and premises-based markets run 38% to 44%. Finance sits alone in the middle at 50%, which is also the figure for the dataset as a whole.
The likely explanation is who sits at a desk. Out-of-office autoresponders, delegation rules and shared-inbox acknowledgements are habits of corporate email. A cleaning company owner or a practice manager is far less likely to have any of that configured, so a bounce is close to the only automatic reply their inbox produces. None of that is proven here; the split is measured, the cause is inference.
Why it changes what a number means. Two campaigns can both report a 1.7% reply rate and be nothing alike. Pointed at marketing agencies, that is about 0.5% real humans. Pointed at cleaning companies, roughly 1.0%, or double. A sender moving between those markets who judges on raw replies will read a halving of real interest as flat performance, and will optimise the wrong thing for months.
The practical consequence is that the harder a market is to reach, the more inflated its raw reply rate looks. Desk-based B2B is the hardest market in this dataset on human replies and has the most flattering raw number. That is the exact combination that produces a campaign everyone believes is working while nothing lands in a calendar.
Percentages in the last column are derived from the two published columns, which are rounded to one decimal place, so read them as approximate. The direction and the size of the split are not sensitive to that rounding.
Should reply rate be measured per email or per prospect?
Per prospect is the more honest number and the one most benchmarks use without saying so. A sequence sending three emails to one person who replies once is a 100% prospect reply rate and a 33% email reply rate. Both are true. Only one describes whether the market is interested.
This is why published benchmarks disagree so wildly. A page quoting 5% and a page quoting 1.5% can be describing identical campaigns measured two different ways, and neither usually says which.
| If a benchmark says | It probably means | Check by asking |
|---|---|---|
| 4% to 8% reply rate | Per prospect, auto-replies included | Are out-of-office replies counted? |
| 2% to 4% reply rate | Per prospect, human replies only | How many emails per prospect? |
| Under 2% reply rate | Per email sent | Is this per send or per contact? |
Two questions settle any benchmark: is it per prospect or per send, and does it include auto-replies. Every figure on this page states both.
What share of replies are actually positive?
About 13%, or roughly one in seven. Of 48,000 human replies, 6,472 were marked positive, meaning interested or a meeting booked. Of those, 1,728 were a confirmed booked meeting. Per email sent that is a positive reply rate of 0.1%.
That ratio is the number most senders have never calculated, and it changes how a campaign should be judged. Six replies out of a thousand emails sounds like failure. If one of those six is interested and the deal is worth $30,000, the campaign is working.
| Per 10,000 emails sent | Expected |
|---|---|
| Human replies | ~80 |
| Auto-replies on top | ~80 |
| Positive replies | ~10 |
| Booked meetings | ~3 |
Those are averages including every campaign that failed, so treat them as a floor rather than a forecast. The useful thing about them is the shape: the drop from replies to positive replies to booked meetings is steeper than most forecasts assume, and planning against reply rate alone consistently overestimates pipeline.
How many emails is one booked meeting?
This is the number every planning conversation actually needs and almost nobody publishes, because it requires carrying a campaign all the way from send to calendar rather than stopping at the flattering metric.
The chain runs: emails sent, then human replies, then positive replies, then booked meetings. Across the whole dataset, 1,728 of the 6,472 positive replies became a confirmed booked meeting, which is roughly one in four. Applying that ratio to each industry's measured positive-reply rate gives the volume behind a single meeting.
| Industry | Positive replies per email | Emails per booked meeting | Emails for 10 meetings a month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cleaning & janitorial | 0.18% | ~2,100 | ~21,000 |
| Restaurants, bars & hotels | 0.18% | ~2,100 | ~21,000 |
| Med spas & healthcare | 0.12% | ~3,100 | ~31,000 |
| Finance, funding & lending | 0.10% | ~3,700 | ~37,000 |
| SaaS & tech | 0.10% | ~3,700 | ~37,000 |
| Recruiting & staffing | 0.09% | ~4,200 | ~42,000 |
| Marketing agencies | 0.09% | ~4,200 | ~42,000 |
| Home services & trades | 0.08% | ~4,700 | ~47,000 |
| Professional services | 0.08% | ~4,700 | ~47,000 |
| Manufacturing & distribution | 0.05% | ~7,500 | ~75,000 |
Read the method before quoting these. The positive-reply column is measured directly. The two right-hand columns are derived by applying one all-dataset ratio, roughly one booked meeting per four positive replies, to every industry equally. That ratio almost certainly varies by market, and nothing here measures how. They are order-of-magnitude planning figures, not per-industry measurements.
Two reasons the real number is usually better. The booked-meeting label is applied by hand in a CRM and goes missing whenever a reply moved to a phone call before anyone updated the record, so it undercounts. And this is a three-year aggregate carrying the learning period, churned accounts and campaigns that never worked. Individual accounts run several times better, as the next section shows.
What it is genuinely good for is sanity-checking a plan before any money is spent. If a proposal implies ten meetings a month from 5,000 emails into manufacturing, the arithmetic says that needs a positive-reply rate fifteen times the measured average. That is not impossible, but it is a claim worth asking someone to source. And if the volume a target requires is clearly unreachable, the fix is a narrower, better-qualified list rather than a bigger send, because every figure in that table moves with targeting far more than with copy.
Why a well-run campaign beats every number on this page
These averages cover three years, 28 workspaces and 1,568 campaigns, including the first ones ever sent, clients who churned, and campaigns that never worked. That is what an honest aggregate looks like, and individual accounts run well above it.
From the same dashboards, in accounts Grow Surely runs:
| Account | Sent | Reply rate | Opportunities |
|---|---|---|---|
| 360Clean, commercial cleaning | 4,800 | 10.97% | 38 |
| Kanopy | 53,000 | 4.42% | 157 |
| Freshwater Creative, creative agency | 160,100 | 3.94% | 200 |
| Grow Surely's own pipeline | 426,100 | 3.19% | 615 |
| AdLeverage, full-service agency | 231,100 | 2.19% | 143 |
The gap between those and the aggregate is the point of publishing both. An average that includes every failure is the only kind worth benchmarking against, and the distance between it and a working campaign is the actual measure of whether targeting and message are doing their job.
Three things move a campaign from the aggregate to the top of that table, and none of them is writing.
List precision. A reply rate below 1% per prospect is almost always a list problem rather than a copy problem. Copy changes move a reply rate by fractions. Pointing the same copy at the right 2,000 people instead of the wrong 20,000 moves it by multiples.
Deliverability. None of this matters if the emails are not arriving. Reply rate is the last metric in the chain and the first one blamed. Domain health, warmup and sending volume decide whether a campaign ever gets the chance to be judged on its message.
Offer. The widest variation in the dataset is between offers, not industries. The same market responds very differently to a request for a call and to something given away first, which is why comparing two campaigns across different offers tells you almost nothing.
How this was measured
Stated in full so the figures can be checked, argued with, and cited.
Source. Campaign analytics pulled directly from Instantly across every workspace Grow Surely operates: 26 client workspaces, Grow Surely's own, and one shared pilot workspace. Duplicates removed.
Period. 30 October 2023 to 12 October 2026. About 87% of volume is from 2026, 11% from 2025, 2% from 2023-24.
Sample. 6,074,430 emails to approximately 3.0 million unique prospects across 1,568 campaigns, an average of 2.0 emails per prospect.
Definitions. A human reply is a reply from a person, excluding auto-responders and out-of-office messages. A positive reply is one marked as interested or meeting booked. Reply rates are given both per unique prospect and per email sent, labelled on every figure.
Exclusions. Three industry rows were removed because each was driven mostly by a single client's offer, which would describe that offer rather than the industry: fitness and gyms, tours and venues, and car dealerships. One workspace showing roughly ten times the average reply rate from 25,000 sends was excluded as a labelling artefact. Industries under 50,000 sends were not published.
Coverage. The industry table covers 4.5 million emails sent by campaigns that still exist; 2.95 million of those sit in the ten published rows. A further 345,000 sent by campaigns whose names carry no industry, and 545,000 from campaigns since deleted, are in the totals but not the industry breakdown.
Why the headline figure is a floor. 6,074,430 excludes clients who have churned and whose workspaces are no longer connected, one workspace that returned an error, and any sending outside Instantly. The true figure is higher and is not published because it cannot be verified.
What this data does not show
Worth stating plainly, because a benchmark that only lists its strengths is marketing.
No open rates. Open tracking is switched off across these accounts, since tracking pixels hurt deliverability and Apple Mail Privacy Protection made the numbers meaningless in 2021. There is no open-rate benchmark here and anyone publishing one post-2021 should be asked how they measured it.
Positive replies are not labelled identically everywhere. Some workspaces use an AI classifier, some are marked by hand. The 13% positive share is a good estimate rather than an exact figure.
Industry is derived from campaign names. It is accurate for most campaigns and unavailable for deleted ones, which is why 545,000 sends sit outside the breakdown.
One agency's clients are not the whole market. This is a large dataset from a single operator with one methodology and a particular client mix, weighted toward North American B2B and service businesses. It is not a random sample of all cold email everywhere.
Averages hide offers. The widest variation here is between offers rather than industries or copy, and offer is the one variable this breakdown cannot isolate.
Citing this data
These figures are free to quote, republish or chart, with attribution and a link. No permission needed and no form to fill in.
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Source | Grow Surely cold email benchmarks, 2026 |
| Sample | 6,074,430 emails to ~3.0 million prospects, 1,568 campaigns |
| Period | 30 October 2023 to 12 October 2026 |
| URL | growsurely.com/blog/cold-email-reply-rate-benchmarks |
Suggested wording: According to Grow Surely's analysis of 6,074,430 cold emails, the average human reply rate is 1.6% per prospect contacted, and auto-replies account for 51% of all replies received.
One request rather than a condition: if a figure is quoted, quote the denominator with it. The whole argument of this page is that a reply rate without "per prospect" or "per email sent" attached, and without saying whether auto-replies are counted, is a number that cannot be compared to anything. Repeating it bare recreates the problem the data exists to fix.
The dataset will be refreshed as volume grows. The figures above carry the date they were pulled so an older citation stays checkable rather than silently going stale.
How to use these benchmarks on your own campaigns
Four comparisons that produce an action rather than a feeling.
1. Recalculate your own rate the same way. Unique human replies divided by unique prospects contacted, auto-replies stripped out. Most senders have never done this and are comparing an inflated internal number against someone else's inflated published one.
2. Compare against your industry row, not the overall average. A 0.9% human reply rate is below average overall and well above average for SaaS. Benchmarking against the wrong row is how a working campaign gets cancelled.
3. If you are under 1% per prospect, look at the list first. That is the level at which targeting is almost always the constraint. Rewriting copy at that point is the most common wasted fortnight in outbound.
4. Judge on positive replies, not replies. One in seven human replies is positive on average. A campaign with a high reply rate and a low positive share has usually found the wrong people and annoyed them efficiently.
Which industries send the most automatic replies to cold email?
Desk-based B2B markets, by a wide margin. Marketing agencies run about 71% of all replies automatic, professional services 70%, SaaS and tech 69% and manufacturing 67%. Field and premises-based markets run far lower: cleaning and home services about 40%, recruiting 39%, med spas 38%. Finance sits in the middle at 50%, which is also the figure across all 6,074,430 emails. The practical effect is that the hardest markets to reach produce the most flattering raw reply rates.
Why do published cold email benchmarks disagree so much?
Four reasons, and almost no published figure states which apply. The denominator is often unstated, and per email versus per prospect differs by the follow-up count. Auto-replies are usually counted, and they are 51% of all replies. Vendors publishing their own numbers rarely include campaigns that failed. And figures from different years and different industries are not comparable, since the spread between the top and bottom industry here is threefold.
How many cold emails does it take to book one meeting?
Between about 2,100 and 7,500 depending on the industry, derived from measured positive-reply rates across 6,074,430 emails and an all-dataset ratio of roughly one booked meeting per four positive replies. Cleaning and hospitality sit at the easy end near 2,100, professional services around 4,700, and manufacturing hardest at about 7,500. Treat these as planning floors rather than forecasts, since well-run individual accounts run several times better than the three-year aggregate.
What is a good cold email reply rate?
Across 6,074,430 emails the average human reply rate is 1.6% per prospect contacted and 0.8% per email sent. Including auto-replies those become 3.2% and 1.6%. A campaign above 2% human replies per prospect is performing well. Below 1% usually indicates a list problem rather than a copy problem.
Do auto-replies count as replies?
They should not. In this dataset roughly 49,000 auto-replies landed against 48,000 human replies, so out-of-office messages are 51% of everything in the reply folder. A benchmark that does not separate them reports a figure about twice its real value. Auto-replies are a deliverability signal, not interest.
What is the average cold email reply rate by industry?
Per email sent: cleaning and janitorial 1.2%, restaurants and hotels 1.0%, med spas and healthcare 1.0%, recruiting 0.8%, finance 0.7%, home services 0.6%, professional services 0.6%, marketing agencies 0.5%, manufacturing 0.5%, SaaS and tech 0.4%. Per-prospect rates run roughly double, since the dataset averages two emails per prospect.
Should reply rate be measured per email or per prospect?
Per prospect is the more honest measure and the one most benchmarks use without stating it. A three-email sequence to one person who replies once is a 100% prospect reply rate and a 33% email reply rate. This is why published benchmarks disagree so widely, and why any figure should state both its denominator and whether auto-replies are included.
What percentage of cold email replies are positive?
About 13%, or roughly one in seven. Of 48,000 human replies, 6,472 were marked interested or meeting booked, and 1,728 became a confirmed booked meeting. Per 10,000 emails sent that works out at roughly 80 human replies, 10 positive replies and 3 booked meetings.
What is a good cold email open rate?
There is no reliable open-rate benchmark and this dataset does not contain one. Open tracking is switched off across these accounts because tracking pixels harm deliverability, and Apple Mail Privacy Protection made open data unreliable in 2021. Anyone publishing an open-rate benchmark measured after 2021 should be asked how.
How was this cold email data collected?
Campaign analytics pulled directly from Instantly across 28 workspaces Grow Surely operates, covering 1,568 campaigns and 6,074,430 emails to roughly 3.0 million unique prospects between 30 October 2023 and 12 October 2026. Three industry rows driven by a single client's offer were excluded, as was one workspace with a labelling artefact.
See what your own numbers look like.
Grow Surely builds the list and runs a free 7-day campaign, then you see your real reply rate against the benchmarks above. No card, no contract.
Get my free meetingsP.S. Before benchmarking against anyone, recalculate your own reply rate with auto-replies stripped out. Most people never have, and the number is usually about half what the dashboard says.